"When men are pure, laws are useless; when men are corrupt, laws are broken."
Benjamin Disraeli
"When men are pure, laws are useless; when men are corrupt, laws are broken."
Benjamin Disraeli
"Income tax returns are the most imaginative fiction being written today."
Herman Wouk
Don't you worry, dear readers, I am not planning on retelling "The Terminator" plot. As the matter of fact, the two technological developments I want to discuss are related to the CFOs' and Controllers' supervisory responsibilities. On the surface (!), they seem to serve a good purpose and could be attractive solutions to some of our common problems.
Every exec with subordinates communicating with financial institutions, investors, key vendors and customers, is vulnerable to their emotional whims, diplomatic abilities and verbal skills. This is especially true with out favorite mode of communication – emails, which remove the recipients' faces and voices thus making the expression of aggression easier.
I have a list of actual stories to be told about relationship damage caused by employees' spiteful writing. And it is not like I don't employ prevention strategies. I give training talks. I impose a sense of supervision by requesting to be copied on all important communications. I even write Post-Its and stick them on the worst offenders' monitors, "Please re-read ALL your emails three times before sending them out." Still, once in a while something happens that requires damage control.
Lo and behold! In NY Times Year in Ideas I read about ToneCheck – "an e-mail outbox filter that works as a sort of emotional spell-check, offers typists a chance to reconsider their words before" sending their missive. I watch the cute animated video attached and my first reaction is like "Finally!!! Hooray!!!"
Then I read further and I forget that I am a CFO with unruly subordinates who require monitoring. I remember that I am a Person and that Freedom of Speech is an important issue for me. Yeah, it's useful in the office environment, but this dangerous program has a capacity to be tuned to ANY CONTENT. I imagine it being installed without my knowledge by my ISP and checking my personal emails for "inappropriate" content as defined by… whoever has the power to do so. How do you feel about it now?
Here is another common problem and even scarier solution for it. How many times we catch our employees attending to their personal business or even playing online games during working hours? We wonder about the hours they waste the costs of it. Frustrated, we think we should like to watch them. So, here you go Computers That See You and Keep Watch Over You. This "wonderful" program sees you and analyzes your facial expressions. And it can be installed on your personal computer without your knowing it.
You know what? I don't want these "solutions." Not even in my office. Let me work harder with my employees on their work attitude, verbal skills and aggression management. If boycotting these products means that we can keep them away from invading our personal privacy, then be it. I hope you click on the links, read about it and agree.
It's like what Benjamin Franklin said,"Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety."
"The human mind treats a new idea the way the body treats a strange protein; it rejects it."
P.B. Medawar (biologist)
"Nothing is either good or bad, but thinking makes it so."
William Shakespeare